Over the past few years, therapy delivered through video calls has moved from a niche option to a mainstream form of psychological support in Singapore. Many people now ask a practical question: is online therapy as effective as sitting in the same room as a therapist?

The research is encouraging, with limits. For the adults and conditions studied most often, online and in-person therapy produce comparable results. The evidence is thinner for some concerns and some groups, and a few findings are less settled than they are often made to sound. This article sets out what the research shows, where it runs out, and how to decide which format suits you.

What Does the Research Say?

The most recent large review is a systematic review and meta-analysis of 20 randomised controlled trials comparing video-delivered treatment with in-person treatment for adult outpatients (Shaker et al., 2023). Nine trials involved PTSD and six involved depressive disorders, with four trials of mixed diagnoses and one of generalised anxiety disorder. Across 17 trials that measured efficacy, the difference between formats was close to zero, and the authors concluded that video-delivered treatment was comparable with in-person treatment. They rated the certainty of that evidence as moderate. Dropout did not differ significantly between formats across all 20 trials.

An earlier review of 12 studies of videoconferencing psychotherapy reached a similar conclusion about symptoms: reductions in target symptoms were noninferior to those in face-to-face therapy (Norwood et al., 2018). Guided internet-delivered cognitive behavioural therapy has also been compared directly with face-to-face CBT, and the pooled results from 20 studies and 1,418 participants suggested similar effects (Carlbring et al., 2018). That evidence concerns structured online programmes with therapist guidance rather than live video sessions, so it supports the wider point only indirectly.

These findings come with limits. Few of the trials in the largest review were rated high quality, most focused on PTSD and depression, and the review found only a single trial of an anxiety disorder (Shaker et al., 2023). Adolescents and couples are not the focus of the evidence summarised here, so similar results should not be assumed for them. If you are weighing options for these concerns, the pages on trauma and PTSD counselling and depression counselling describe how The Bridge Counselling approaches them.

The Therapeutic Alliance Online

The therapeutic alliance is the quality of the working relationship between client and therapist, and the evidence on it is less settled. In the 2018 review, alliance ratings were lower in videoconferencing than in face-to-face therapy. The difference was not statistically significant, but the confidence interval was wide enough that a meaningful difference could not be ruled out, and noninferiority was not established (Norwood et al., 2018). The 2023 review found no significant difference in alliance across six trials, although results varied widely between trials (Shaker et al., 2023).

In plain terms, a strong relationship is possible online, and the evidence does not yet show that it is always as strong as it is in person.

What Patients Describe

Patients' own accounts add useful detail. In a small qualitative study of 11 patients, participants described the emotional relationship as altered after a move to remote sessions. They described the loss of body language, eye contact and tone of voice, which they felt increased the risk of misunderstanding. Some also found it easier to express feelings at a distance, and remote therapy was still seen as a good enough alternative when needed (von Below et al., 2023).

Because the study was small and measured experiences rather than outcomes, it is best read as a reminder that fit matters. It is not evidence that either format gives better or worse results.

Why Online Therapy Can Work Well

The Relationship Still Matters

Nothing about video prevents a working relationship from forming. In clinical experience, many clients find that after a session or two the screen fades into the background and the conversation becomes the focus. That is a clinical observation rather than a research finding, and the patient accounts above show it is not everyone's experience.

Increased Accessibility

Online therapy removes geographical barriers. It can help people who travel frequently, relocate overseas, keep demanding work schedules, care for children or relatives, or have mobility challenges. In Singapore, attending a session without commuting can reduce friction and make consistency easier.

Continuity across a relocation is one of the clearer practical arguments for working online. The considerations that internationally mobile clients face are discussed in counselling for expats in Singapore.

Comfort of Familiar Surroundings

Some clients feel more relaxed speaking from their own home. For people dealing with social anxiety or panic symptoms, starting somewhere familiar can make it easier to begin.

Home is not always private or settled, though. Patients in the qualitative study described having to create their own therapeutic frame at home (von Below et al., 2023), and a shared household can limit what a client feels able to say. Whether home helps or hinders depends on the person and the work being done.

When In-Person Therapy May Be Preferable

Severe or High-Risk Presentations

Counselling in either format is not an emergency service. If you are in acute crisis or concerned about your safety, hospital-based or emergency care is the right place to begin, as set out below. For severe presentations more broadly, some clients and clinicians prefer in-person sessions because distress can feel easier to notice and additional support easier to arrange. In the qualitative study, some patients avoided remote therapy because they feared they would not receive enough support (von Below et al., 2023).

Strong Preference for Physical Presence

Some people feel that being in the same physical space carries a sense of depth and grounding that is difficult to replicate online. Therapy is not only about evidence. It is also about fit, and a strong preference for face-to-face contact is a good reason to choose it.

Environmental Limitations

Not everyone has a private, quiet space at home or a stable internet connection. If confidentiality cannot be maintained during a video session, in-person therapy may be more secure.

Common Concerns About Online Therapy

“Will It Feel Impersonal?”

This is a frequent worry. Many clients are surprised by how connected they feel, and emotion, silence and reflection all occur online much as they do in a consulting room. Others find that something is lost, as the patient accounts suggest. It is reasonable to try a session and judge for yourself, and what to expect from an initial session is explained in what to expect in your first counselling session in Singapore.

“What About Confidentiality?”

Confidentiality depends on both the platform and your surroundings. Counsellors are ethically bound to protect client privacy regardless of the format, and it is reasonable to ask which platform your counsellor uses and how your information is protected. You can read about The Bridge Counselling's approach on the confidentiality page.

“Is Online Therapy Less Serious Than In-Person Therapy?”

Online therapy is intended to be the same clinical work delivered through a different medium. The research above suggests that outcomes are comparable for the conditions studied. The medium does change some things, however, such as nonverbal cues and the setting, and those changes are worth discussing with your counsellor.

What Actually Determines Effectiveness?

The research above compares formats. It cannot tell you whether a particular counsellor will suit you. As general guidance, and not as a finding from these studies, the following matter whichever format you choose:

  • The competence and training of the counsellor

  • The quality of the working relationship

  • Your readiness for change

  • Consistency of attendance

  • Clear goals and collaborative work

For a deeper explanation of how to judge the relationship, see how to know if your counsellor is the right fit. The wider question of choosing a counsellor is covered in how to choose a therapist in Singapore.

Online and In-Person Sessions at The Bridge Counselling

At The Bridge Counselling, individual and couples sessions can be held in person or online. An individual counselling session costs $140 for 60 minutes and a couples counselling session costs $190 for 60 minutes. The fee is the same in both formats, because the preparation and focus are the same, and the Counselling Fees page sets out the payment terms.

Details of each format are on the online counselling and in-person counselling pages.

When Urgent or Hospital-Based Care Is the Better Starting Point

Counselling, online or in person, is not an emergency service, and counsellors do not prescribe medication. If you are in crisis, are concerned about your safety, or may need a psychiatric assessment or medication, begin with a hospital-based or medical service. In an emergency, seek help at the 24-hour Emergency Services at the Institute of Mental Health or another hospital. Further information is on the Emergency Resources page.

Choosing the Format That Suits You

In clinical experience, the most effective therapy is the one you are able and willing to attend consistently, with a counsellor you trust. That is a clinical view and not a study result, but it is a sensible guide when the research shows comparable outcomes for many people.

If you are unsure, you can raise the question of format when you book a session, and the counsellor can talk through what suits your situation. More about what an initial session involves is on the Your First Visit page.

Frequently Asked Questions

For the adults and conditions studied most often, research suggests comparable symptom improvement and similar dropout rates. The evidence is thinner for some concerns, and the strength of the working relationship online is less settled. A counsellor can help you judge which format suits your situation.

The largest review summarised here was based mainly on trials of PTSD and depression, with only one trial of an anxiety disorder (Shaker et al., 2023). Suitability depends on the person and the concern, so it is best discussed with your counsellor.

Yes. An individual session costs $140 for 60 minutes and a couples session costs $190 for 60 minutes, in either format.

Counsellors are ethically bound to protect client privacy in any format. Confidentiality online also depends on the platform and on having a private space, so it is worth asking your counsellor about both.

You need a private space, a reliable internet connection, and a device you can use comfortably. If you cannot arrange privacy at home, mention this when booking so that options, which may include in-person sessions, can be discussed.

No. In a crisis, or if you may need a psychiatric assessment or medication, start with your GP, a polyclinic or a hospital-based service.

References

  • Carlbring, P., Andersson, G., Cuijpers, P., Riper, H., & Hedman-Lagerlöf, E. (2018). Internet-based vs. face-to-face cognitive behavior therapy for psychiatric and somatic disorders: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 47(1), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2017.1401115

  • Norwood, C., Moghaddam, N. G., Malins, S., & Sabin-Farrell, R. (2018). Working alliance and outcome effectiveness in videoconferencing psychotherapy: A systematic review and noninferiority meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 25(6), 797–808. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2315

  • Shaker, A. A., Austin, S. F., Storebø, O. J., Schaug, J. P., Ayad, A., Sørensen, J. A., Tarp, K., Bechmann, H., & Simonsen, E. (2023). Psychiatric treatment conducted via telemedicine versus in-person modality in posttraumatic stress disorder, mood disorders, and anxiety disorders: Systematic review and meta-analysis. JMIR Mental Health, 10, Article e44790. https://doi.org/10.2196/44790

  • von Below, C., Bergsten, J., Midbris, T., Philips, B., & Werbart, A. (2023). It turned into something else: Patients' long-term experiences of transitions to or from telepsychotherapy during the COVID-19 pandemic. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, Article 1142233. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1142233

Filed under: Finding Support
Sharon Dhillon

About the Author

Sharon Dhillon

Sharon is an experienced counsellor and psychotherapist in Singapore, providing affordable mental health support to individuals and couples.

Read More Posts or View Full Bio